F654 — Human Review Protocol Audit
F654 covers “Human Review Protocol Audit”. The canonical record classifies it as documented, based on 2 source artifacts and 0 original source figures. The highlighted measurements are Gate Pass = No, F653 Score Fields = naturalness_1_5 · depth_1_5 · clarity_1_5 · non_template_1_5, and F653 Average Score 1 5 = 0.
Purpose and research question
F654 documented whether the joint F653/F657 human-review protocol and local review console were ready to collect ratings. It evaluated packet completeness and tooling readiness separately from the still-unperformed human scoring gates.
Method
F654 audited two 100-row human-review packets, one for F653 and one for F657. It counted unique prompts, answer rows, completed ratings, duplicates, and invalid-for-gate rows, and verified the local console fields and CSV export; the protocol was ready but both packets still had 0/100 completed human ratings.
Documentation basis
2 source artifacts and 0 phase-specific figures are recorded for this phase.
Evidence highlights
- Protocol ready: true
- Console ready: true
- F653 completed ratings: 0/100
- F657 completed ratings: 0/100
- F653 gate: false
- F657 gate: false
Recorded evidence
| Gate Pass | No |
|---|---|
| F653 Score Fields | naturalness_1_5 · depth_1_5 · clarity_1_5 · non_template_1_5 |
| F653 Average Score 1 5 | 0 |
| F653 Positive Yes No Rate | 0 |
| F653 Gate Pass | No |
Follow-up evidence
These measurements are retained from the shared source package but belong to a later or contextual phase and are not part of F654’s primary metric grid.
| F657 Score Fields | utility_1_5 · depth_1_5 · correctness_1_5 · naturalness_1_5 |
|---|---|
| F657 Average Score 1 5 | 0 |
| F657 Positive Yes No Rate | 0 |
Public evidence and source figures
The current public archive does not attach a benchmark image to this phase. The source artifacts and recorded measurements remain listed below.
Result and interpretation
Both packets contained 100 unique prompts and 100 answer rows, and the protocol plus console were ready. However, each packet had 0/100 completed human ratings and 100 invalid-for-gate rows, so both F653 and F657 gate results remained false. F654 itself has no explicit terminal verdict.
Key results
- Gate Pass
- No
- F653 Score Fields
- naturalness_1_5 · depth_1_5 · clarity_1_5 · non_template_1_5
- F653 Average Score 1 5
- 0
- F653 Positive Yes No Rate
- 0
- F653 Gate Pass
- No
Evidence sources
Values on this page are reproduced from the archived phase record and the source artifacts below. No new benchmark was run to create this page.
- HUMAN REVIEW PROTOCOL AUDIT 653 657 (JSON)
- HUMAN REVIEW PROTOCOL AUDIT 653 657 (MD)